Artists | Issues | CD Reviews | Interviews | Concert Reviews | DVD/Video Reviews | Book Reviews | Who We Are | Staff | Home


Paradise Theater

Review by Gary Hill

This is a concept album but the story line doesn’t really seem all that consistent. It’s also a fairly standard Styx disc that feels a bit like they were going through the motions. Still there are a few tracks that really standout here. Besides, the truth is, Styx is a good enough band that even if they are phoning in some of the performances, it’s still pretty good.

This review is available in book format (hardcover and paperback) in Music Street Journal: 2009  Volume 3 at

Track by Track Review
A.D. 1928
This is a mellow Dennis DeYoung balladic cut. It’s pretty and perhaps a bit like the “Boat on a River” type of track. It’s an introduction to the album.  It segues straight into the next piece.
Rockin' the Paradise
Here we get a smoking Styx hard rocker that’s just plain killer.
Too Much Time on My Hands
This was one of the big hits from the disc. It’s definitely another classic rocker with some trademark Styxisms all over it.
Nothing Ever Goes as Planned
At times this feels to me like a harder rocking Supertramp. There’s a definite bluesy quality to the number. It’s got some of that DeYoung show time texture, too, though. 
Best of Times
Another balladic cut, this is pretty standard fare for what Styx were doing in those days. It’s got Dennis DeYoung’s signature everywhere. 
Lonely People
A sound effects interlude type thing starts this off and the band launch out into a killer jam from there – with a synthesized jazz band sound. They drop it way down to a rather funky sound for the verse.  They rock it out from there in a killer sound that combines that classic hard edged Styx sound with some rather funky sounds. This is probably the most proggy song on the disc. While it’s not a single – or a track that many might think of when they remember this disc, I’d say it’s my favorite piece on show here. It’s dynamic and diverse and just plain cool. 
She Cares
From the best track on the disc we move to something that’s perhaps more forgettable. This is obviously a Tommy Shaw number – and he does write some great songs. Here, though, he gives us a piece that’s got a bit of a 1950’s texture to it. This almost feels more like something from Billy Joel than Styx. It’s not terrible, just not strong either.  Trouble is, it sits between two of the best cuts on the whole album. 
I’ve always loved this song. It’s a definite James Young track and it is just plain cool. It works between a mellower dramatic movement and a nearly metal powerhouse jam.  Funny thing is, I know of three songs with the same title (Black Sabbath and Ace Frehley delivered the other two) and all of them rock! 
Half-Penny, Two-Penny
This one is very nearly heavy metal. It’s always felt to me like it would have fit on Pieces of Eight quite well. It’s a bit like “Miss America,” too. I’d say you wouldn’t have to think long to chalk this up as a James Young composition. There are some cool proggy moments here, too. 
A.D. 1958
They bring it all back home with this piece that seems to tie up a lot of the musical elements in one neat little package. We get some saxophone on this number and it’s a good track if not a standout. It serves as a nice bookend to the opening cut.
State Street Sadie
This is just an instrumental movement that ends the CD.
You'll find concert pics of this artist in the Music Street Journal members area.
You'll find an audio interview of this artist in the Music Street Journal members area.
Return to the
Styx Artist Page
Return to the
Tommy Shaw Artist Page
Artists Directory

   Creative Commons License
   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.

    © 2024 Music Street Journal                                                                           Site design and programming by Studio Fyra, Inc./