Let’s start with the positives on this album. The Afterdarks put together a smoking bunch of songs that alternately call to mind such artists as The Ramones, Billy Idol, Elvis Presley, George Thorogood, The Cramps and The Lords of the New Church – along with others. They create fiery versions of the punky side of rockabilly. There’s not a song on here that doesn’t purely rock. “So, what’s the problem?” you might ask.
The downside to this disc is that sometimes more is not really more. Had they cut the disc shorter it would have worked better. Why? Because there’s only so much you can do with three chords. That’s why music moved beyond the original rock and roll and why punk rock had a built in short shelf life. It all starts to sound the same after a while and this set isn’t immune to it. That said, it’s very late in the album before the monolithic nature sets in. Also there are a couple acoustic songs near the end that, had they been set earlier on the disc, would have gone a long way to keep it from ever sinking in. I should also mention that the last three tracks on my copy skip – so I’ve done my best to review them without really hearing every moment of them.
All in all, though, this is a strong disc. It should please fans of rockabilly and punk rockers, too. I just think that a little restraint and not trying to pack as many songs as possible into the set would have made for a stronger release. Of course, in the age of MP3’s I’m probably one of a dying breed who actually listens to whole albums, so it might be a moot point.
This review is available in book format (hardcover and paperback) in Music Street Journal: 2010 Volume 1 at lulu.com/strangesound.