Artists | Issues | CD Reviews | Interviews | Concert Reviews | DVD/Video Reviews | Book Reviews | Who We Are | Staff | Home
 

Jon Anderson

and the Band Geeks - Live - Perpetual Change

Review by Gary Hill
This live album with accompanying DVD is a Yes album, except in name. I have heard Yes live so many times over the years. I’ve seen them in concert close to 20 times. I own every official live album and have heard plenty of “unofficial” ones. If there is something I know, it’s what a Yes concert sounds like. This definitely fits that equation.

The band performing with Jon Anderson here really captures the Yes sound completely. So, if you think of this as a new live Yes album, you’ll have a good idea of what this is. How you feel about the necessity of that will probably go a long way toward sorting your feelings on this set.

The recording quality (and the video on the DVD) is great. The performances are inspired and effective. I think I might have preferred a few deep cuts over some of the more played numbers. That said, “Gates of Delirium” qualifies as close to that. All in all, this is a strong live album from a band who you would believe is Yes if you didn’t know better.

This review is available in book (paperback and hardcover) form in Music Street Journal: 2025  Volume 3. More information and purchase links can be found at: garyhillauthor.com/Music-Street-Journal-2025.
Track by Track Review
CD 1
                         
Yours Is No Disgrace

This really feels like it could have been lifted from any number of live Yes performances over the years, and I’ve heard a lot of live Yes recordings. I don’t hear anything that really stands out here, but on the other hand, every live Yes show has its own identity, its own nuances. The same is true of this.

Perpetual Change

The real power of this performance is that again, it could easily pass as a long lost Yes recording. Yet it’s a modern version. It has its own slight variants that each live show has. That said, it has some of the fiercest guitar soloing I’ve ever heard on this number.

Close to the Edge

Here we have another faithful rendition of a classic Yes track. I really love some of the synthesizer nuances as it’s heading in the mellower section mid-track.

Heart of the Sunrise

Now I can hear some definite differences on the bass work here. That’s not a bad thing at all. It still feels like the kind of thing Chris Squire would have played. It’s just different from anything he ever actually played. And, it’s not a huge departure. There are a few other things that just feel a little different, too, reminding the listener that while this is very faithful, this is a Jon Anderson performance, not a Yes performance.

Starship Trooper

This one gets a very faithful arrangement and performance. It again feels like it could have come from an old Yes live recording. This thing gets so fierce later in the instrumental section. It still stays true to sounding like Yes, but it feels like one of the best Yes performances ever of the piece.

Awaken

On the one hand, a lot of this live performance of the Yes epic feels very faithful. That said, there are parts that feel more intense.

CD 2

 

                                 
And You and I

There are some unfamiliar sounds on this early that I don’t think work all that well. Once it gets out of the first vocal movement, and the track builds up more, that resolves, though. I’m probably just too familiar with this song to appreciate the change, but the sound I’m talking about is a repeated single tone throughout the early parts that just sticks out to me. It really mars my appreciation of the performance. That said, once that’s gone, this really gels and captures the magic I expect.

Your Move - I've Seen All Good People

Here we get another faithful rendition of a Yes classic. It works well, but doesn’t really stand out.

Gates of Delirium

Now, this epis is one that’s more of a lost gem. I’ve heard Yes do it live before, but it’s not the mainstay that so much here is. That rarity of live performances makes this one special. The scorching hit rendition makes it even more so.

Roundabout

Now, from a piece where the rarity makes it special to the most over-played Yes song of all time. This is a solid rendition, but I’m largely over this song after hearing it so many times over the past 50-plus years.

You'll find concert pics of this artist in the Music Street Journal members area.
 
Return
 
Google

   Creative Commons License
   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.

    © 2025 Music Street Journal                                                                           Site design and programming by Studio Fyra, Inc./Beetcafe.com