Artists | Issues | CD Reviews | Interviews | Concert Reviews | DVD/Video Reviews | Book Reviews | Who We Are | Staff | Home
 

Dave Brubeck

Classic Live Albums 1952-54

Review by Gary Hill

For me, Dave Brubeck, with all of his various groupings, is one of the real jazz greats. His sound just resonates with me in ways that some jazz artists don’t. He is in my short list of my favorite jazz musicians. This three-CD set collects nearly all the live recordings of Brubeck from 1952 to 1954. I’m not sure why they didn’t include all of them, but even so, this selection from five live albums is great. I enjoy every moment of it, even though some tracks stand taller than others.


This review is available in book (paperback and hardcover) form in Music Street Journal: 2025  Volume 3. More information and purchase links can be found at: garyhillauthor.com/Music-Street-Journal-2025.


Track by Track Review
CD 1
                            
From the album Jazz at Storyville
                                   
Over The Rainbow

Based on the melody you would expect, this piano solo moves in jazz directions and paints some particularly cool sonic pictures. While I said it was a piano solo, and the bulk of it is, some horn comes in later.

You Go To My Head

A mellow and smooth moving jazz arrangement is on the menu here. While everything about this arrangement works well, the piano really sells it. There are some pretty and rather melancholy moments built into this.

Crazy Chris

Bouncy and more energized, this little tune is a lot of fun. There is some killer piano jamming built into this thing.

Medley; Give A Little Whistle, Oh, Lady Be Good

In some ways this isn’t a big change. It has some great grooves and really dances and vibes, though.

Tea For Two

The saxophone on this track really brings so much magic and charm to the proceedings. The number is a great piece of jazz that’s among the highlights of the set for me.

From the album Jazz at the College of the Pacific
                      
On A Little Street In Singapore

There are some intriguing shifts and changes in place here. This is a cool tune with some contrasts and a lot of classy instrumental work.

I May Be Wrong

This is solid, but not really a standout. It’s just the kind of jazz one expects here.

Blue Moon

Now this track really elevates things. I love the bass on it, but everything about this arrangement just works so well. It’s another standout of the set. It has a lot of passion and a killer groove built into it.

Let's Fall In Love

Energized and really grooving, this cut is another standout. I really love the jamming on this thing so much.

Jeepers Creepers

I’ve always loved this song. Of course, the film by the same title brought some different feelings to it. This jazz exploration wanders pretty far from the main melodies. It’s a classy tune that works really well. The frantic piano jamming later is so cool.

The Trolley Song

A mellower and pretty melodic number, this is classy. It’s another solid number.

My Heart Stood Still

This is a fast-paced piano solo.






Laura

While not entirely a piano solo, that instrument is the primary focus here.

CD 2

                        

From the album Jazz at the College of the Pacific

                                      

All The Things You Are

I really love the energy and groove of this track. It gets pretty driving before it’s done. The drums are on fire here, but so is the piano work. The recording on this isn’t as good as some of the rest, though, feeling a little muddy and distorted at times.

Lullaby In Rhythm

This groove is another classy one. It also features a drum showcase later. They really seems to get into this thing and really pour everything into it. It’s not that the other tunes were lacking passion at all. It’s just that everything seems to get even more intense here.

I'll Never Smile Again

Another with a lot of focus on the piano work, this track has some great grooves and melodies. It’s also energetic and classy.

I Remember You

I really love everything about this track. It’s not any kind of paradigm shift, but it’s just an effective and captivating live jazz number.

For All We Know

A slower, mellower arrangement gets things underway here. The track explores with a lot of style and charm.

From the album Jazz at Oberlin

                                                 

Perdido

This jazz classic gets a scorching hot live telling with lots of great soloing built into it.

Stardust

A mellower excursion, this is another effective piece of music.

These Foolish Things Remind Me Of You

Horn features prominently on this number. Later on the focus shifts to piano for a while. This cut has an almost freeform vibe a lot of the time, getting into some pretty weird, yet tasty, territory.

The Way You Look Tonight

This has some smoking hot jamming built into it. It’s energized and grooving, and the crowd is responding. This is another standout tune on the set.

From the album Brubeck & Desmond at Wilshire Ebel
                                   
Let's Fall In Love

Piano gets us underway here. The track evolves from there to a killer jazz jam that has some playful vibes built into it.

CD 3
                            
From the album Brubeck & Desmond at Wilshire Ebel
                                                 
I'll Never Smile Again

Some great piano and horn work is on display here. The melodies are strong and the whole groove works really well.

Stardust

I love everything about this tune, but I especially love the piano work on it. The whole tune just grooves with so much style and charm.

All The Things You Are

Another high energy jazz romp, this features exceptional instrumental work from all the musicians.

Why Do I Love You

The energy and groove here is positively on fire. We have some killer instrumental interplay.

Too Marvellous For Words

The bass driving this is great. Then again, that same description works for both the piano and horn work. Or maybe I should use the word “marvellous.” The piano does get pretty crazed at times.

Out Of Nowhere

There is a real magical sense and vibe to this track. There are some exceptionally cool melodies and passages here.

From the album Jazz Goes to College

                               

Le Souk

This jam is so intense. It features a driving, up-tempo arrangement. It also has some of the best instrumental work of the whole box set. This is definitely a stand out that reaches some soaring heights.

Take The 'A' Train

I’ve always been a big fan of this piece. While this might not be the quintessential version of the track, it’s so strong. If you’ve only heard one Dave Brubeck song, this is probably it. So, it’s very appropriate that we get a version here. This is a great groove that has plenty of magic packed into it.

The Song Is You

Another great jazz groove, I like this one a lot. The bass is exceptional, but so is everything else here.

Don't Worry 'Bout Me

A slower, rather bluesy jam is on the menu here. This has a great groove and a lot of style.

I Want To Be Happy

We don’t get a big change here. Instead we get another effective piece of music. There is some great jamming on the tune, but what else do you expect, really?

 
Return
 
Google

   Creative Commons License
   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.

    © 2025 Music Street Journal                                                                           Site design and programming by Studio Fyra, Inc./Beetcafe.com