Artists | Issues | CD Reviews | Interviews | Concert Reviews | DVD/Video Reviews | Book Reviews | Who We Are | Staff | Home
Progressive Rock CD Reviews

Anthony Phillips

Private Parts & Pieces IX - XI

Review by Gary Hill

This new box set is classy. You get three previously released Anthony Phillips albums, Private Parts & Pieces IX-XI. While you might think that makes this a three CD set, you'd be wrong. There are actually four discs here because the final one is made up of previously unreleased music that didn't make those albums, but was recorded at the same time as them. If you've followed Phillips' career at all, you'll know that he's hard to pin down in terms of musical genre. While he got his start with Genesis, that hasn't been the defining point of his sound. Indeed, the three main albums here range from acoustic guitar based sounds to classical piano and electronic. Each of those sounds dominates one of the albums. Other than one song here, this is an instrumental. It should be noted that I've reviewed the three main albums individually, too, and those reviews are included here for the track by track sections as it's the same music. Each CD here gets an overall review after the title, followed by the track reviews.

This review is available in book (paperback and hardcover) form in Music Street Journal: 2018  Volume 3. More information and purchase links can be found at:

Track by Track Review
Disc One
Private Parts and Pieces IX - Dragonfly Dreams
I've heard and reviewed a large cross-section of Anthony Phillips' music. One thing you can count on with him is quality. What you can never be certain about is the type of music you'll get. Here we have an album of mostly instrumental music. It has a bit of a New Age vibe to a lot of it. While probably the majority of it is acoustic guitar based, there is also some keyboard music here. All in all, this is quite a pretty and entertaining set.
Delicate and quite intricate acoustic guitar work serves as the "opener" referenced by the title.
In the Valleys
Here we have another gentle acoustic number, but it's perhaps more "song" like than the opener.
Something Blue
Even further into the "song" like direction, this has a bit of travelling folk music vibe. Beyond that, though, the overall concept isn't changed dramatically. The gentler, mellower section later in the piece is particularly pretty.
There is a definite jazz guitar vibe to this piece of music. At less than a minute in length, it's a short one.
Feeling a bit like Synergy or Tangerine Dream, this is a big change with more of an electronic arrangement. The keyboards on this are quite atmospheric, but still manage to convey melody at the same time. This lands in the neighborhood of New Age music.
Under the Ice
Feeling almost like an extension of the previous piece, this atmospheric number seems both bleak and beautiful. This does feel like a slow moving, barren vista found under the ice.
Sarah Blakeley's Evening
This builds out into more of a rocking zone. It definitely has elements of old Genesis sound. It's still intricate. It's just more powered and vibrant. It's short at less than a minute and a half long.
She'll Be Waiting
The only song on the disc with actual vocals, this is a pretty cut. It's part progressive rock and part folk rock.
Still Time
A short guitar based piece, this is another intricate number.
Hills of Languedoc
Gentle acoustic guitar leads this piece out, as well. There is a lot of energy in the number.
Luigi Palta's Confession
Coming in with much more of a rocking (but still acoustically driven) sound, this has a definite folk rock kind of vibe to it.
The Tears of Pablo Piraguas
Atmospheric textures bring this piece into being.
Melancholy Flower
The title really fits this track. This is intricate and pretty, like a flower, but there is a melancholy texture to it. It's a slow moving piece.
Night Song
There are some operatic female vocals here, but they are more like instrumentation than actual vocals. This is another pretty and slow moving piece, but it's more electronic than the last one. It is quite atmospheric.
Chinese Walls
This is the epic of the disc, weighing in at 17 and a half minutes. It starts with the acoustic elements in slow moving, intricate textures. It gradually grows outward from there. While the volume level doesn't really change, the cut makes its way through a number of movements and themes, and it does intensify at times. It's hard to believe this piece is as long as it is because, despite the fact that it's strictly acoustic guitar, it never feels tired or redundant, and the time just seems to fly by.
Old Faithful
Atmospheric keyboard textures hold it together as the acoustic guitar weaves pretty patterns and melodies.
Summer Ponds and Dragonflies
This rises up delicate and very beautiful. I'm reminded of Phillips' work in Genesis to a large degree.
Lost and Found
More electronic, this number is bouncy and rather fun.
Disc Two
Private Parts & Pieces X - Soirée
Anthony Phillips first came to prominence as the original guitarist for Genesis. Since leaving that group he has released a very extensive catalog. All of his albums are of high quality, but there is a wide range of sound changes from set to set. This one is all instrumental and mostly classical piano based. It's quite a strong album, really.
Sad Ballerina
A song that seems to have the perfect title, this is a piano solo that seems to depict that particular ballerina.
Final Lights
Another piano solo, this one seems to be more upbeat in terms of mood. It's very much a pretty classical number.
Sultry Leaves
This has a bit more of a tentative vibe to it. It grows gradually, but is another very classical music oriented piece.
I love the delicate little fills on this classically oriented piano piece. It has a great energy and moving arrangement.
While this isn't a huge change in terms of the type of music, this is quite powerful and dynamic. It has gentle sections and more bombastic ones.
Another potent piano solo, while this isn't a huge change in terms of style, it is different thematically.
Venetian Mystery
I love the tone and rather melancholy mood of this piece.
Moving both in terms of emotion and the energy level of the track, this is a very powerful number. Yet it also has some forays into pretty oddities as it works its way forward. It is quite a dynamic number.
Pretty and at times gentle, this is also especially evocative. There is somehow an olde world vibe to this in a rather ethnic way at times.
The Oregon Trail
Fast paced and dramatic classical piano work drives this number forward in style.
Another pretty piano solo, this not greatly changed from the other material around it, but is a strong entry with its own identity.
Gentle and a bit dreamlike, this is quite satisfying.
There is a great contrast on this composition. Part of it is forceful and bombastic. Other parts are sedate and delicate. They work together nicely.
Fallen Flower - Dedicated to the Memory of Diana, Princess of Wales
Somehow this reminds me of the type of music you might hear at the start of a soap opera. It is gentle and a bit sad. I suppose given the dedication and title that makes sense.
Noblesse Oblige
Another pretty piece of music, this has some powerfully emotional sections.
Hope of Ages
This is a poignant and soaring kind of number. It has a lot of bombast and drama in the mix. It also has gentle respites built in as a sort of resolution.
Trippy atmospheric electronic sounds are the basis of this number, making it a big contrast to the rest of the album. Yet it really fits well within the sound of the set.
Rain Suite
This is so powerful and dynamic. It's also rather extensive at six minutes of piano music. It starts with a fast moving section that plays through. Then around the half way mark it drops way down and starts to build back up from there. This next section gets particularly powerful.
After You Left
Presenting a contrast to the louder and energized movement that closed the last piece, this is slow moving and delicate. It's sad and also pretty.
Summer's Journey
This isn't a big change, but it's another pretty classically based piece of music.
Disc Three
Private Parts & Pieces XI - City of Dreams
Each album Anthony Phillips releases is quite different from the ones around it. This particular set is made up of atmospheric electronic music that calls to mind things like Tangerine Dream and Synergy. It's a mostly restful collection of fairly short pieces. It's also a fine entry in the Anthony Phillips catalog.
City of Dreams I
Rather mellow and atmospheric, this is also quite lush and electronic in some ways. It's a short piece at just over a minute long.
As you might expect from a piece called "Piledriver," this comes in more rocking, but also quite synthesized. It's a powerful bit of electronic music.
King of the Mountains
Lush and very pretty, this has definite classical music elements. Yet it's also atmospheric, at least in terms of the opening section. Some electric guitar rises up after a time, weaving some great lines of distorted melody. This makes me think of both Tangerine Dream and Pink Floyd quite a bit.
Coral Island
Gentle electronic elements create a pretty sonic tapestry on this piece.
Astral Bath
More energetic keyboard sections bring this into being. Again, I can hear comparisons to Tangerine Dream, but also to Synergy. It shifts toward the more textural as it continues.
City of Dreams II
A dream-like quality is built over the top of this piece. It grows upward within that same concept.
Air & Grace
Delicate and quite pretty, piano drives a lot of this number.
Tuscan Wedding
Textural and pretty, this is a tasty number.
Mystery Train I
I love the building modes on this piece. It's a intricate piece of electronic music that works quite well.
Sunset Pools
More textural sounds are in place on this slow moving number.
Sea & Sardinia
Somehow this atmospheric number really does feel like an underwater excursion to me.
Watching While You Sleep
Another slow and textural piece, this is gentle and pretty.
Night Owl
This is just around a minute long and quite sedate and textural.
The Deep
Again, there is a vibe like that of the ocean here. It really does feel like drifting deep underwater.
City of Dreams III
Not a big change, this is more atmospheric electronic music. It's less than a minute long.
Mystery Train II
There are some parts of this that make me think of Mike Oldfield a bit. This is a bit more intricate and melodic.
Star's End
This is another short textural piece. It has a bit of a dreamlike quality to it.
Desert Flower
Atmospheric elements bring this into being, and it rises upward gradually.
Night Train to Novrogod
This number has a good amount of energy. There is a percussive kind of element that almost feels like the "click clack" of a train on the tracks.
Sea of Tranquillity
Gentle and quite pretty, there is almost an Asian element to this.
39 Steps
Pretty melodies move this piece in electronic ways.
Lake of Fire
This is a short piece that has a definite symphonic element to it despite it's sedate texture.
Realms of Gold
Still quite textural and pretty, there is an almost otherworldly element here. There are some chorale voices later in the piece, but they seem to be synthesized rather than real.
City of Dreams IV
Rising upward via intricate sounds, this has a dense arrangement despite its sedate nature.
Days of Yore
Guitar textures bring this into being and move it forward while still keeping much of the sound of the rest of the disc.
Across the Steppes
There is actually a feeling of clouds floating above the Earth on this number.
Act of Faith
There is some particularly pretty piano at the heart of this cut. In fact, it's essentially a piano solo.
Grand Master
More textural modes are the basis of this sedate number.
Mystery Train III
This short piece is another that makes me think of Mike Oldfield.
Anthem for Doomed Youth
There are synthesized chorale vocals here. This does have a melancholy vibe to it and is pretty. A piano based part takes over later with atmospheric electronic elements replacing it later in the track.
The Homecoming
Bell chiming sounds and other atmospherics are on display on this number.  It turns more classical near the end. There is a false ending and then some dramatic (but still sedate) elements rise up to actually serve as the closing section.
Disc Four
Private Parts & Extra Pieces III
The final disc of this set is made up of previously unreleased material. This music is other recordings and alternate versions of pieces that made it onto the three main discs here. Honestly, perhaps this set is more balanced than the others because it has a smattering from the three other discs. This doesn't feel like leftovers because it has some solid stuff on display.
High Roller
An acoustic guitar number, this is a full on rocker. It definitely lands in the folk prog vein, but is seriously rocking. It also has plenty of intricate elements.
Piano Drama Movement I
While this is rather classical in nature, it really has a lot of energy and drive built into. There are some sections of particularly intricate piano work, too. At almost six and a half minutes, this is an extensive piece.
Sunset Drifter
Almost a blues rocker, this still has a prog edge to it. I love the melodic electric guitar soloing over the top.
Lostwithiel Link
I dig the electronic ambient textures on this. It calls to mind Mike Oldfield a bit.
Roads in Between
Intricate acoustic guitar is on the menu here. This gets quite effective and feels a bit like early Genesis.
Shimmering Peaks
Electronic and almost rhythmic, there is a cool groove to this piece.
Castles and Courtships
Piano creates the textures and melodies of this cut in a somewhat classical way. There are several movements and moods built into this piece. At about five and a half minutes of music, this has plenty of space for Phillips to explore. He makes good use of that space.
Brand New Cadillac
I love this intricate guitar based piece of music. There are some intriguing melodies at play here. Again this isn't that far removed from the kind of thing you'd expect from early Genesis.
Ocean of Stars
A mellower kind of textural sound is at the heart of this intriguing number. The melodic elements move slowly along.
Pablo Dries Out
I love the picked guitar work on this number. It's very much in line with a cross between classical guitar and folk music.
Lost Monolith
Keyboard textures create a pretty and rather poignant piece of music here.
A Simple Man
Piano brings this in with style. The cut is just under a minute long and purely a piano solo.
Night Song (Alternate Mix)
This piece doesn't have the voices that are heard on the other version. I think I like it better in this form. It seems very sad.
There is a bit of a droning guitar element with other sounds creating intricate melodies over the top of it.
Constellation of Hope
Spanish guitar and electronic textures make up the musical concepts.
Piano Drama Movement III
A fast paced and dramatic piano solo is the concept here. This is a real powerhouse of a piece with plenty of classical music in the mix. There is a gentle segment later that eventually takes this to its closing.
Heaven's Gate
More textural electronic music, this is a pretty cut that works quite well. It starts powerful and lush and seems to wash out like the tide, gradually fading downward in intensity.
Lost and Found (Alternate Mix)
There is a bouncy sort of electronic prog motif at the heart of this version of the earlier piece. This isn't a big change from the other rendition.
More CD Reviews
Metal/Prog Metal
Progressive Rock

   Creative Commons License
   This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.

    © 2024 Music Street Journal                                                                           Site design and programming by Studio Fyra, Inc./